• ENEN
    • IT IT
    • FR FR
    • DE DE
    • ES ES
PARTNER LOGIN
  • ENEN
    • IT IT
    • FR FR
    • DE DE
    • ES ES

Auriga

  • COMPANY

    • About Us

    • Auriga History

    • Group

    • Our Values

    • Our Network

      • Partnerships

      • Certifications

      • Suppliers

    • CSR (ethical code)

      • CSR – Corporate Social Responsibility

  • BANKING

    • Overview

    • Needs

      • Channel Integration

      • Monitoring network

      • Marketing & Customer Relations

      • Accessibility of banking service

      • Corporate Banking

      • Banking Data Analysis

      • Branch of the Future

    • Products and Solutions

      • Shared Services

        • WinWebServer Architecture

        • Proactive Network Monitoring

        • One to One Marketing

      • ATM / Kiosks

        • WWS ATM

      • Internet / PC

        • WWS PC

      • Mobile Banking and Payments

        • WWS Mobile

      • Electronic payments

        • MyBank

      • Bank Marketing & Digital Signage

        • WWS One to One OMNIA

        • WWS Signage

        • WWS Perfect

        • WWS RSS Feed

        • WWS Simply Feed

      • Network Monitoring & Fraud Management

        • WWS Proactive Monitoring Manager

        • WWS Fraud Management System

        • WWS Simply Check

      • Call Centre

        • WWS Help Desk

      • Cash Handling

        • WWS Cash Handling

        • WWS Cash Management

      • Digital Invoicing and Document Management

        • WWS e-Invoicing

      • Branch

        • WWS Fill4Me and Bank4Me

        • WWS Greæter

        • WWS Customer Management

      • Business Analytics

        • WWS Business Analytics Management

        • WWS Asset Management

      • Cyber Security Platform

        • Lookwise Device Manager

  • NEWS & MEDIA

    • News

    • Press Release

    • Press Review

    • Blog

    • Videos

  • RESOURCES

    • White Papers

    • Customer stories

    • Research

    • Brochures

  • CONTACT

    • Contact us

  • CAREERS

    • Work for Us

    • Online application

    • Job vacancies

Blog

  • Home
  • News & Media
  • Blog
  • What next for branch & ATM closure guidelines in UK?
What-next-for-branch-ATM-closure-guidelines-in-UK-Auriga-blog-EN

What next for branch & ATM closure guidelines in UK?

27 July 2022 / Blog

This week, the UK financial regulator, the Financial Conduct Authority closed its consultation on how banks manage branch and ATM closures and conversion and whether its guidance on these matters should be changed.

This consultation was significant because the FCA suggested that previously agreed best practices on how banks plan and communicate the change of in-person banking services were not working well.

This should not surprise us. We have remarked in previous occasions that customers are not contacted to be asked to go branch-less but have this loss of channel choice made for them. While banks preach a lot about the importance of omnichannel banking, they forget that in-person banking services is also a channel. Banks either simply cut it or underinvest in how in-person and in-branch self-service banking are integrated with other digital channels.

So what might come out of this consultation?

From the FCA and the banks, we do need to see clearer formulae for why a specific branch should be shuttered. Banks tend to roll out general numbers of customers who regularly use digital services, but these don’t mean the same customers never visit a branch at risk of closure. There is little evidence that banks do an in-depth analysis let alone consultation of a branch’s customer base to understand the real proportion of customers who would be affected. Even when that percentage may seem small, it may account for a substantial number of people and those customers are likely to over-represent groups who are most vulnerable to the loss of access to cash and financial services locally. Indeed the definition of “vulnerable” customers is far too narrow and ignores groups who are massively inconvenienced by closures.

It is a matter of infrastructure

Quite simply branch and ATM service reviews need to be done in a much more considered fashion than currently. Banks take a sausage machine approach, pumping out a one size fits all justification and solution. This typically runs as too few people use bank branches and those that need in person banking services can go to their local post office. However, despite the best efforts of the post office, this is a degraded service to the one that is being closed. Few post offices have the facilities to match a closed branch and access to bank services must compete for attention with everything else a post office must offer from stamps to posting parcels to ordering a passport.

One of the other issues that should be addressed by the FCA and the industry is how some banks are promoting new micro branches as a response to closures. While these look like branded branches, the reality is they are simply information shops without the trained staff or systems to help a customer with a range of specific everyday issues.

Banks should be encouraged to roll out pop up branches that can be introduced to provide banking services in new locations quickly and easily. However, it is critical that these have banking facilities, and these can be cost effectively provided by next generation self-service digital banking systems.

Phony branches that lack in-person banking services are counterproductive and again illustrate how some bank’s omnichannel strategies are a broken mess.

Banks will continue to make the case for closures because of changing customer demographics. The FCA does need to ask if a bank has accurately assessed how automation and digital self-service could bring down branch operating costs while keeping services available.  There are proven cases of this new branch model delivering impressive results like how the Italian Banca Carige is rolling out new digital and smart bank branches that cut operating costs by more than a third.  Branches like these can be wholly automated, staff-less 24 hours, and even shared.

Using #NextGenBranch solutions, customers can access all the branch services in assisted self-service mode around the clock and interact with the bank’s consultants via video banking for both easy and complex transactions in a safe and personalized way.

This technology allows customer-facing employees to be able to spend more time focusing on more complex activities that require the added value of human interaction, as well as more time to train themselves in new skills, with positive effects on customer experience. It reduces branch management costs, while maintaining access to financial services, and generating new revenue streams through add-on services.

White Label Branches

Sharing infrastructure among different banks could also play a role in minimising the impact of branch and ATM closures. Banks could adopt a “white label branch” model, where a single location acts as a shared service centre for all banking-related activity, regardless of which bank the customer holds an account with. Similarly, multiple banks could pool their investment in new ATMs to assure widest local coverage of free ATM services. ATM pooling is already a feature of banking in Belgium where there is a top-down commitment to providing access to cash at ATM’s within 5km of their citizens’ doorsteps. Other countries are taking a similar approach and the UK could learn from them.

What’s next?

Overall banks are too keen to rush at branch closures regardless of how they create access to cash and financial service deserts. There are alternatives that should be explored before closures are considered. Let’s hope that any new guidance from the FCA helps banks be more ambitious and committed to preserving and improving in-person banking services and ATM provision.

     
  • Tweet
Tagged under: ATM closures, branch, UK
  • News
  • Press Release
  • Press Review
  • Blog
  • Videos
  • Infographics

SUBSCRIBE TO THE NEWSLETTER

Subscribe today and you will get:

  • News on software solutions
  • Customer stories
  • Invitations to industry events and conferences
  • Detailed reports
  • Market research
  • and much more!
CONTACT

HEADQUARTER - BARI
Via Don Luigi Guanella, 17
70124 Bari - Italy

TEL: +39.080.5692111

info@aurigaspa.com

Milan office
Rome office
Brussels office
London office
Pamplona office
Mexico City office

BUSINESS CONTACTS
Niccolo Garzelli - Auriga - Footer

Niccolò Garzelli Milan office
niccolo.garzelli@aurigaspa.com

MARK ALDRED London office
mark.aldred@aurigaspa.com

Stefano Cipollone Milan office
stefano.cipollone@aurigaspa.com

Daniela Azzolini Milan office
daniela.azzolini@aurigaspa.com

MARTIN ESPINELMexico City office
martin.espinel@aurigaspa.com

lukasz-feluch

ŁUKASZ FELUCHLondon office
lukasz.feluch@aurigaspa.com

RUDY DE WOLFBrussels office
rudolf.dewolf@aurigaspa.com

EXPLORE
  • About Us
  • WinWebServer
  • Blog
  • White Papers
  • Research
LATEST NEWS
  • ATMaaS Managed Serviced blog en

    Keeping Customers Engaged with ATM-as-a-Service

    14/03/2023
  • cms-business-solution-press-release-img

    Auriga forges new ATM fintech partnership to further grow Latin American business

    28/02/2023
  • Banking industry accolades for LDM news

    Banking industry accolades for LDM

    23/02/2023

Connect with us

SUBSCRIBE TO THE NEWSLETTER

Auriga Spa - Copyright © 2023 - All rights reserved | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy
P.I. 05566820725 - Capital € 1.196.055 i.v. - R.E.A. 426675

TOP
We, and third party websites you may interact with via our site, use cookies to collect site usage data and improve your experience, this includes permanent and profiling cookies.
By clicking ‘Accept’ you agree to allow cookies, however you can disable this through your browser settings at anytime. If you opt to totally or partial disable cookies, this might compromise some features on the website.
For more information on our cookie policy, go to the Legal Notice page.
Accept

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT